Overview

Consultation paper

On 15 July the AER published three draft working papers on Overall rate of return, Equity and Debt. Our three working papers focus on key technical aspects of the rate of return and provide the AER’s preliminary positions and issues for further consideration, in particular:

  • Overall rate of return draft working paper provides an overview of our rate of return framework, our decision-making process and our positions to date. It also explores a number of discrete topics that relate to the overall rate of return.
  • Equity draft working paper explores a number of technical aspects of estimating the expected return on equity. In particular, we want to check that the approach we employ is robust in a range of market conditions.
  • Debt draft working paper discusses the data that is available to allow us to set a return on debt that aligns with the debt costs that network businesses experience.

AER - Rate of return - Overall rate of return draft working paper - July 2021

Authors
AER
Content type
Document

AER - Rate of return - Equity draft working paper - July 2021

Authors
AER
Content type
Document

AER - Rate of return - Debt draft working paper - July 2021

Authors
AER
Content type
Document

Economic Insights - Report to the AER - Methodological issues in estimating the equity beta for Australian network energy businesses - 30 June 2021

Authors
Economic Insights
Content type
Document

CEPA - Report to the AER - Relationship between RFR and MRP - 16 June 2021

Authors
CEPA
Content type
Document

Graham Partington and Stephen Satchell - Report to the AER – WACC and Leverage - 19 May 2021

Authors
Graham Partington and Stephen Satchell
Content type
Document

AER - Sensitivity of regulated revenue to the rate of return - April 2019

Authors
AER
Content type
Document

AER - Draft working papers - Stakeholder briefing slides - 19 July 2021

Authors
AER
Content type
Document

Stakeholder forum

-

The AER hosted three online forums for stakeholders to ask questions of the AER and interact directly to hear each other’s perspective on the working papers. The forums were held on:

  • 4 August 2021 – Overall rate of return draft working paper
  • 9 August 2021 – Debt draft working paper
  • 11 August 2021 – Equity draft working paper

The AER would like to thank those who presented at the forum, as well as those who were able to attend on the day to listen to the views of other stakeholders.

AER - Overall Rate of Return Forum presentation - 4 August 2021

Authors
AER
Content type
Document

APGA - Overall Rate of Return Forum presentation - 4 August 2021

Authors
Australian Pipelines and Gas Association (APGA)
Content type
Document

CRG - Overall Rate of Return Forum presentation - 4 August 2021

Authors
Consumer Reference Group (CRG)
Content type
Document

ENA - Overall Rate of Return Forum presentation - 4 August 2021

Authors
Energy Networks Australia (ENA)
Content type
Document

NICE - Overall Rate of Return Forum presentation - 4 August 2021

Authors
Network of Illawarra Consumers of Energy (NICE)
Content type
Document

AER - Debt Omnibus Forum presentation - 9 August 2021

Authors
AER
Content type
Document

CRG - Debt Omnibus Forum presentation - 9 August 2021

Authors
Consumer Reference Group (CRG)
Content type
Document

ENA - Debt Omnibus Forum presentation - 9 August 2021

Authors
Energy Networks Australia (ENA)
Content type
Document

NICE - Debt Omnibus Forum presentation - 9 August 2021

Authors
Network of Illawarra Consumers of Energy (NICE)
Content type
Document

NSG - Debt Omnibus Forum presentation - 9 August 2021

Authors
Network Shareholder Group (NSG)
Content type
Document

AER - Equity Omnibus Forum presentation - 11 August 2021

Authors
AER
Content type
Document

APGA - Equity Omnibus Forum presentation - 11 August 2021

Authors
Australian Pipelines and Gas Association (APGA)
Content type
Document

CRG - Equity Omnibus Forum presentation - 11 August 2021

Authors
Consumer Reference Group (CRG)
Content type
Document

ENA - Equity Omnibus Forum presentation - 11 August 2021

Authors
Energy Networks Australia (ENA)
Content type
Document

MEU - Equity Omnibus Forum presentation - 11 August 2021

Authors
Major Energy Users Inc (MEU)
Content type
Document

NSG - Equity Omnibus Forum presentation - 11 August 2021

Authors
Network Shareholder Group (NSG)
Content type
Document

Submissions

-

We invited interested parties to make submissions on our three draft working papers on Overall rate of return, Equity and Debt. Submissions closed on 3 September 2021.

TasNetworks - Submission - Debt - 3 September 2021

Authors
TasNetworks
Content type
Document

TransGrid - Submission - Overall rate of return, Equity and Debt - 3 September 2021

Authors
Transgrid
Content type
Document

APGA - Submission - Overall rate of return, Equity and Debt - 3 September 2021

Authors
Australian Pipelines and Gas Association (APGA)
Content type
Document

APGA - Submission - Overall rate of return, Equity and Debt - Attachment 1 - CEG Stranding risk report - 3 September 2021

Authors
Competition Economists Group (CEG)
Content type
Document

APGA - Submission - Overall rate of return, Equity and Debt - Attachment 2 - CEG Asset beta report - 3 September 2021

Authors
Competition Economists Group (CEG)
Content type
Document

Energy Queensland - Submission - Overall rate of return, Equity and Debt - 3 September 2021

Authors
Energy Queensland
Content type
Document

Ausgrid - Submission - Debt - 3 September 2021

Authors
Ausgrid
Content type
Document

Ausgrid - Submission - Equity - 3 September 2021

Authors
Ausgrid
Content type
Document

Ausgrid - Submission - Overall rate of return - 3 September 2021

Authors
Ausgrid
Content type
Document

SAPN, CitiPower, Powercor, United Energy - Submission - Overall rate of return, Equity and Debt - 3 September 2021

Authors
CitiPower Powercor United Energy and SA Power Networks
Content type
Document

Jemena - Submission - Equity - 3 September 2021

Authors
Jemena
Content type
Document

Jemena - Submission - Attachment 2 - NERA Stranding Risk Report - Equity - 3 September 2021

Authors
NERA Economic Consulting
Content type
Document

ENA - Submission - Debt - 3 September 2021

Authors
Energy Networks Australia (ENA)
Content type
Document

ENA - Submission - Equity - 3 September 2021

Authors
Energy Networks Australia (ENA)
Content type
Document

ENA - Submission - Equity - Attachment A - Houston Kemp MRP estimate report - 3 September 2021

Authors
HoustonKemp
Content type
Document

ENA - Submission - Overall rate of return - 3 September 2021

Authors
Energy Networks Australia (ENA)
Content type
Document

AusNet Services - Submission - Overall rate of return, Equity and Debt - 3 September 2021

Authors
AusNet Services
Content type
Document

Endeavour Energy - Submission - Overall rate of return, Equity and Debt - 3 September 2021

Authors
Endeavour Energy
Content type
Document

The CFO Group - Submission - Debt - 3 September 2021

Authors
AusNet Services
Victoria Power Networks (VPN)
ElectraNet
Jemena and SA Power Networks
Content type
Document

AEC - Submission - Overall rate of return, Equity and Debt - 3 September 2021

Authors
Australian Energy Council (AEC)
Content type
Document

APA - Submission - Overall rate of return Equity and Debt - 3 September 2021

Authors
APA Group
Content type
Document

SACOSS - Submission - Overall rate of return and Equity - 3 September 2021

Authors
South Australian Council of Social Service (SACOSS)
Content type
Document

CRG - Submission - Overall rate of return, Equity and Debt - Volume 1 - 3 September 2021 - Corrected

Authors
Consumer Reference Group (CRG)
Content type
Document

CRG - Submission - Overall rate of return, Equity and Debt - Volume 2 - 3 September 2021

Authors
Consumer Reference Group (CRG)
Content type
Document

CRG - Submission - Overall rate of return, Equity and Debt - Sapere Systematic risk and equity beta report - 3 September 2021

Authors
Sapere Research Group
Content type
Document

MEU - Submission - Overall rate of return, Equity and Debt - 3 September 2021

Authors
Major Energy Users Inc (MEU)
Content type
Document

GIIA - Submission - Equity - 3 September 2021

Authors
Global Infrastructure Investor Association (GIIA)
Content type
Document

QTC - Submission - Debt - 3 September 2021

Authors
Queensland Treasury Corporation (QTC)
Content type
Document

QTC - Submission - Equity - 3 September 2021

Authors
Queensland Treasury Corporation (QTC)
Content type
Document

NSG - Submission - Overall rate of return, Equity and Debt - 3 September 2021

Authors
Network Shareholder Group (NSG)
Content type
Document

AGIG - Submission - Overall rate of return, Equity and Debt - 3 September 2021

Authors
Australian Gas Infrastructure Group (AGIG)
Content type
Document

Supporting information

Energy Networks Australia’s (ENA) submission to our three draft working papers on Overall rate of return, Equity and Debt included a discussion on the use of scenario testing as one of the cross checks of the overall rate of return and also proposed a calibrated Dividend Growth Model (DGM) as a method to address the concerns about DGMs expressed in the 2018 Rate of return instrument. The ENA has provided information on its scenario testing and the outputs from its calibrated DGM. We have published the ENA’s scenario testing model below which also contains outputs from its calibrated Dividend Growth Model.

ENA models user guide

Authors
Energy Networks Australia (ENA)
Content type
Document

ENA models – 2022 RORI scenario testing and calibrated DGM

Authors
Energy Networks Australia (ENA)
Content type
Document

ENA - A calibrated dividend growth estimate of the market risk premium - 28 April 2022

Authors
Energy Networks Australia (ENA)
Content type
Document